Laguna is much better in terms of softness and durability as compared to Alcantra or Nappa leathers from what I've heard. It will also get softer as it ages. Some have said they noticed very small cracks in it, but many say it is the most durable. The color below is beautiful to my eyes...

 

Both are high quality leathers and here are the characteristics of each as I understand them:

Laguna - has an aged "pull-up" effect to the leather which gives it a "vintage" look. It is resilient and long lasting

Nappa - softer and smoother than most leathers and is processed so that the natural leather grain is preserve. It is treated with water-soluble colorants which makes it fade resistant, so excellent for automotive seating. It is however, susceptible to scratching

I have the Alcantara/Nappa combo in my Scat - it is very nice. At first, I was unsure if I would like it, but I have now come to prefer it to the full leather seats I have had in other vehicles because with spirited driving, you don't slide around on the Alcantara.

 

I have the Laguna leather in my 2016 SRT. I can’t say enough good things about it even eight years later still looks close to new and is the most supple and great quality leather I’ve ever had in any interior of any of my cars.

 

I have it in my 2015 Hellcat (black Laguna) and it was one of the three features of my cat that convinced me to buy it. The other two features were the supercharger and stick shift. Soooo.... OK, Laguna leather seats come in 3rd cuz truth be known, I'd drive that badassed cat sitting on a milk crate.

 

I also have the Laguna Leather in my 16 HellCat and to be honest I'd take my 1320 Alcantara back (and over it) anyday.
I miss the look and the feel of the softer warmer Alcantara, especially the steering wheel (even know many dont like it)

 

Thanks for the info. Not a fan of the pumpkin orange seating in modern cars. I know it's supposed to invoke feelings of baseball mitts.